Sunday, 15 December 2013

Let Toys Be Toys: High Street Stores Are Less Sexist This Christmas

Our survey reveals that gender-based toy marketing is falling out of favour in toy stores, with significantly fewer ‘girls’ and ‘boys’ signs in toy shops this Christmas.

In November, Let Toys Be Toys mystery shoppers across the UK and Ireland took part in a survey in designed to gauge the impact of the campaign.

The results are good news: the percentage of shops using ‘girls’ and ‘boys’ signs has reduced by 60% compared with when the campaign began last Christmas, dropping from half of all shops a year ago to just a fifth today.

Says campaigner Kerry Brennan,

“While there’s still a long way to go to address sexism in the toy industry, the changes in major retail chains like Debenhams are just brilliant to see. They’ve replaced pink and blue ‘Girls’ and ‘Boys’ signs with new colourful signs that say ‘Vehicles’, ‘Superheroes’, ‘Soft Toys’, and ‘TV Characters’, among others. Everything is much easier to find and children are no longer being sent the message that science and adventure are only for boys, crafts and nurturing play only for girls.

“Through the grass roots efforts of a small group of dedicated volunteers, the support of over ten thousand parents and educators, and the willingness of many retailers to listen to the concerns of their customers, a year after the campaign began we can clearly see the difference that consumer voices are making on this issue.”

Top performers
Hobbycraft tops the list of stores marketing toys without relying on gender stereotypes, with second and third place going to Toymaster and Fenwick.

The results showed Fenwick, Debenhams and TK Maxx to be the most improved, all having recently decided to stop using ‘girls’ and ‘boys’ signs and display toys by category.
Worst performers
The worst culprit for using gender to sell products was supermarket chain Morrisons. Despite promising in July to take down ‘Boys Toys’ and ‘Girls Toys’ signs many were still to be seen in November. Where they have been replaced, toys are still grouped by gender, with prominent pink and blue ‘Toys’ signs.

In general supermarkets were shown to favour stereotyping the most, while independent stores were the least likely to use gender stereotypes in toy marketing.

Of the fourteen major retailers we contacted this year and asked to remove ‘girls’ and ‘boys’ signage from shop floors or own-brand toy packaging, seven have already done so (Hobbycraft, Boots, TK Maxx, The Entertainer, Debenhams, Fenwick, Next) and five are in the process of doing so (Toys R Us, Marks and Spencer, Tesco, Sainsbury, Morrisons). See our Who’s doing what? page for more details.
Signs are coming down, but many stores still organise by gender
The survey results are not all good news. Just over 70% of stores still used some kind of gender cues, (such as grouping stereotypically girls’ toys together, rather than organising by type, eg princess dressing up near the dolls rather than with other role play or dressing up), with 40% of stores using gender to sell the majority of their toys.

Says campaigner Rebecca Brueton,

“We still have a way to go. We made getting rid of the signs our priority this year and it’s largely worked. Even so, you can still find plenty of shops promoting outdated and limiting ideas, giving children the message that science is only for boys and creativity for girls for example. This is the 21st Century. We wouldn’t accept such outdated thinking for adults, why do we allow it for our children?”